Superannuation vs Share vs Property - which one wins?!
  • 13 September 2019

Superannuation vs Share vs Property - which one wins?!

Hi All,

Hope you’ve had a great week!

Following on from my article last week - we had a lot of people asking us:

Is MY Superannuation fund one of the worst-performing in the country?

The report we have looked at 600 of the largest superannuation funds, to find the most overpriced and underperforming superannuation funds in Australia

If you are 35 years old and earning the average Australian income of just on $80,000 per year and have your superannuation with one of these companies, you would be just on $200,000 worse off when you retire!

Australians with their superannuation in these funds, face an average of 2% in fees, when many of the better performing funds charge around 1%.

Collectively these worst performing funds, manage $7 billion in superannuation money, which ends up costing Australians just over $150 million per year in extra fees!

Which brings us to the question, what is better, Super, Shares or property?

Well . . . Russell Investments put together a long term investing report to rank the best performing asset class for the last 10 and 20 years.

 No real surprises to see the results :

For the past 10 years on a gross of fees and tax basis, 

  1. Residential property was the top performing asset class followed by 
  2. Global shares (hedged) and 
  3. Global fixed income (hedged) Australian listed property, cash and Australian shares were the bottom three asset classes, as shown in Figure 4.

For the past 20 years on a gross of fees and tax basis, 

  1. Residential property was the top-performing asset class, followed by 
  2. Australian shares, 
  3. Global shares (hedged) and 
  4. Global listed property (unhedged), while cash, global shares (unhedged) and Australian fixed income were the bottom three asset classes, as shown in Figure 5.

Pretty clear, simple and the easy winner is . . . Residential Property!

For over a quarter of a century now, Property Club has been assisting Club members to safely invest in residential property giving the best returns like the above for the long term!

Make contact with your Property Mentor or enquiries@propertyclub.com.au for further information, so you can get the best results like detailed above!

Troy Gunasekera | National Manager

Related Posts

From February 2026, Borrowing Gets Harder. Plan Before It Does.

From February 2026, Borrowing Gets Harder. Plan Before It Does.

From 1 February 2026 , new lending rules will change how Australian banks assess higher borrowing levels. For many buyers and investors, the outcome will not hinge on the property they choose. It will hinge on access to finance. If buying, investing or refinancing is part of your plans in 2026, this change matters....

One in Four Aussies Are Reassessing Their Homes: What This Means for You in 2026

One in Four Aussies Are Reassessing Their Homes: What This Means for You in 2026

New Canstar research shows that many Australians are quietly reassessing their housing situation. According to the survey, more than one in four homeowners are considering their next move over the coming year. The figures vary across the states, with Queensland showing the highest proportion of people thinking about...

The Christmas Property Myths That Cost Investors Money

The Christmas Property Myths That Cost Investors Money

Every year the property market slows as people turn their attention to travel Christmas shopping and family time. With so much noise around the holidays it is easy for investors to absorb advice that sounds reasonable but has little basis in how the market actually works. Property Club continues to watch these...

Become a Member Today!

Our mission is to help the average Australian learn the property market dynamics and discover the amazing opportunities that exist in real estate.